Gold vs ETFs: Which Is a Better Inflation Hedge?

Inflation is the general increase in the prices of goods and services over time. It reduces the purchasing power of money, meaning that you can buy less with the same amount of money in the future. Inflation can erode the value of your investments, especially if they do not keep up with the rising prices.

An inflation hedge is an investment that aims to protect you from the loss of value due to inflation. It typically involves investing in assets that are expected to maintain or increase their value, or that are tied to inflation. Some examples of inflation hedges are gold, property, commodities, and exchange-traded funds (ETFs).

In this article, we will compare gold and ETFs as inflation hedges and discuss their pros and cons.

Man holding a bullion bar

What Is Gold?

Gold is a precious metal that has been used as a store of value and a medium of exchange for thousands of years. Gold is considered a safe haven asset, meaning that it tends to retain its value or increase in times of economic uncertainty, geopolitical turmoil, or market volatility.

Gold is also widely regarded as an inflation hedge because its price in U.S. dollars is variable. If the dollar loses value due to inflation, gold tends to become more expensive. Therefore, an owner of gold is protected (or hedged) against a falling dollar, as they can sell their gold for more dollars in the future.

What Are ETFs?

ETFs are funds that track the performance of a basket of securities, such as stocks, bonds, commodities, or currencies. ETFs trade on stock exchanges like regular shares, meaning that they are easy to buy and sell. ETFs offer diversification, liquidity, transparency, and low fees.

ETFs can also be used as inflation hedges, depending on what they invest in. For example, some ETFs track the prices of commodities, such as oil, gas, metals, or agricultural products. These commodities tend to rise in value when inflation increases, as they reflect the higher costs of production and transportation.

Other ETFs track the performance of sectors or industries that are expected to benefit from inflation, such as energy, utilities, consumer staples, or health care. These sectors tend to have stable demand and pricing power, meaning that they can pass on the higher costs to their customers.

Pros and Cons of Gold

Gold has some advantages and disadvantages as an inflation hedge. Here are some of them:

Pros

Historical performance: Gold has a long history of preserving its value over time. According to the World Gold Council1, gold has outperformed all major currencies over the past 50 years in terms of purchasing power.
Limited supply: Gold has a limited supply, meaning that its value is not affected by changes in monetary policy or government spending. Unlike fiat currencies, gold cannot be printed or created at will.
Global demand: Gold has a global demand, meaning that its price is influenced by factors beyond any single country or region. Gold is used for jewellery, industrial applications, and investment purposes by individuals, institutions, and central banks around the world.

Cons

No income: Gold does not pay any interest or dividends, meaning that it has an opportunity cost compared to other income-generating assets. When interest rates rise, gold becomes less attractive as an investment.
Storage costs: Gold requires storage costs, such as fees for vaults or security. These costs can reduce the net return on gold investments.
Price volatility: Gold can be subject to price volatility due to speculation, market sentiment, or external shocks. Gold prices can fluctuate significantly in the short term, making it risky for investors who need liquidity or stability.

Pros and Cons of ETFs

ETFs also have some advantages and disadvantages as inflation hedges. Here are some of them:

Pros

Diversification: ETFs offer diversification across different assets, sectors, industries, or regions. This can reduce the risk of investing in a single asset or market that may underperform or decline in value due to inflation.
Liquidity: ETFs are highly liquid, meaning that they can be easily bought and sold on stock exchanges. This can provide flexibility and convenience for investors who need to adjust their portfolios quickly or frequently.
Transparency: ETFs are transparent, meaning that they disclose their holdings, fees, and performance on a regular basis. This can help investors make informed decisions and monitor their investments.

Cons

Tracking error: ETFs may not perfectly track the performance of their underlying assets or indexes. This can result in a difference between the expected and actual returns of the ETF. Tracking error can be caused by factors such as fees, rebalancing, or market inefficiencies.
Counterparty risk: ETFs may involve counterparty risk, meaning that they rely on third parties to fulfil their obligations. For example, some ETFs use derivatives, such as futures or swaps, to replicate the performance of their underlying assets. If the counterparty fails to deliver on its contract, the ETF may suffer a loss.
Tax implications: ETFs may have tax implications, depending on the type and jurisdiction of the ETF. For example, some ETFs may distribute dividends or capital gains to their shareholders, which may be subject to taxation. Other ETFs may incur taxes on their internal transactions, which may reduce their net returns.

How to Choose Between Gold and ETFs

There is no definitive answer to whether gold or ETFs are a better inflation hedge. The choice depends on various factors, such as your investment objectives, risk tolerance, time horizon, and personal preferences.

Here are some questions to consider when choosing between gold and ETFs:

What is your goal? Are you looking for capital appreciation, income generation, or wealth preservation? Gold may be more suitable for wealth preservation, while ETFs may offer more opportunities for capital appreciation or income generation.
What is your risk profile? Are you comfortable with volatility, uncertainty, or complexity? Gold may be more volatile and uncertain in the short term, while ETFs may involve more complexity and counterparty risk.
What is your time frame? Are you investing for the short term, medium term, or long term? Gold may perform better in the long term, while ETFs may offer more flexibility and liquidity in the short term or medium term.
What is your preference? Do you prefer physical assets or digital assets? Do you prefer active management or passive management? Do you prefer global exposure or local exposure? Gold is a physical asset that requires active management and offers global exposure. ETFs are digital assets that can be passively managed and offer local or global exposure.

Gold and ETFs are both popular inflation hedges that have their pros and cons. The choice between them depends on your personal situation and preferences. You may also consider diversifying your portfolio with a combination of gold and ETFs to balance the benefits and risks of each asset.

Disclaimer: This article is intended as an opinion piece and does not constitute financial advice. Investing in bullion carries risks, and individuals should conduct thorough research and consult with a qualified financial advisor before making any investment decisions.

Links for places to start investing now:

Try our bullion tracker today and see the benefits for yourself!

Our bullion tracker is the easiest way to track the value of your precious metals holdings. It's fast, easy to use, and affordable.

Here are just a few of the benefits of using our bullion tracker:

Stay organised: Keep track of all of your precious metals holdings in one place.
Make informed decisions: Know the current value of your holdings so you can make better decisions about when to buy and sell.
Save money: Avoid overpaying for precious metals by knowing the current market value.

Plus, we offer a free 30-day trial so you can try our bullion tracker risk-free.

Start your free trial now: https://goldsilverstacker.com